All,
1030 Local Time
26 November 1942
Near Chouigoui, French Tunisia
At dawn the tanks of 10th Panzer Division crashed into Blade Force's rear, back at Chouigoui Pass. Colonel Watters' 1st Battalion, 1st Armored Regiment, bore the brunt of the assault. Equipped solely with M3 Stuarts, the American tankers did not fare well, as one might expect (according to 29-year old 2nd Lieutenant Freeland A. Daubin, a platoon leader in A Company, 1st Battalion, 1st Armored Regiment, he "...discovered why his unit's 37mm weapons had performed so poorly even at point-blank range. In the chaos if its first operation, his battalion had been issued training ammunition instead of the newer armor-piercing rounds, which were still sitting int he supply depots of Algiers."). Nevertheless, TF Reisman was tasked to send any available tanks and tank destroyers back to Chouigoui Pass in order to stem the flow of panzers from the north.
Captain Avery, the Tank Company commander, immediately grabbed up the tanks he had to hand and began pushing back to the west, towards Chouigoui Pass. The column briefly became disoriented, so that it actually passed the German column and ended up approaching it from the southeast;* the Germans saw the fledgling American armored force coming and dispatched a small detachment to handle it.
This is a fictional engagement, but it still should have happened with Americans in the east and Germans in the west, but I forgot about that when I set the table up and so I had to make up that part about Captain Avery becoming disoriented and having to turn around, thus attacking from the southeast, sorry ;)
Overview, north is up. There is a walled farm at bottom left (St Joseph's Farm, other elements of Blade Force had fought a battle here yesterday); other than that, the battlefield is framed by rocky escarpments and, broken only by sand dunes (which are impassable to vehicles) and rocky ground.
This is a straight up tank fight, no infantry or support weapons (well, some US halftracks used as tank destroyers), and no real finesse, just gonna duke it out at point-blank range. Every now and again I like to do this, but two issues: 1) I really need to do it on a bigger table, 4' x 4' does not cut it (for me) in 15mm, and 2) this is the one area where I feel 5Core Company Command doesn't shine, it just doesn't feel right to me for fast-paced armored actions. But I think I have a solution, courtesy of my good buddy Shaun. He and I were discussing the rules and even though we were discussing different facets, he brought up a different mechanism and it hit me that it would (probably) be perfect for tank-on-tank fights: rather than using the regular "Five Men in Normandy"-style activation, I should try the "Five Men at Kursk"-style activation.
Alas, Shaun and I's conversation occurred after I'd already played this, but I've resolved to play out at least one more tank-on-tank fight in North Africa (Kasserine, maybe El Guettar? Maybe both? Yeah, probably both!) on at least a 5' x 4' table, maybe even full 6' x 4', and to use 5MAK-style activation.
**Briefly, for those wondering:
-5MIN: when it's your turn, roll 1D6. If it's a 1, everyone gets to move, without drawing reaction fire, but they're not allowed to shoot. If it's a 2-5, count your total number of stands, divide it by three, and activate that many stands (with some provisions for 'group moves). If it's a 6, everyone that's able to fire (good order or pinned and has an enemy unit in line of sight) gets to shoot, but after it's all over, every enemy unit that's able to fire gets to take a shot.
-5MIN: when it's your turn, roll 1D6. If it's a 1, everyone gets to move, without drawing reaction fire, but they're not allowed to shoot. If it's a 2-5, count your total number of stands, divide it by three, and activate that many stands (with some provisions for 'group moves). If it's a 6, everyone that's able to fire (good order or pinned and has an enemy unit in line of sight) gets to shoot, but after it's all over, every enemy unit that's able to fire gets to take a shot.
-5MAK: when it's your turn, count up your total number of stands and roll that many D6. Assign each D6 to a stand and carry it out, in order of your preference. 1s mean that stand gets to move without drawing reaction fire, 2-5 means that stand gets to move and fire, but is subject to react fire, and a 6 means that stand gets to fire (with a bonus, if I recall correctly, and without being subject to return fire, also if I remember correctly, but I'm not sure, it may allow for return fire).
The opposing forces, with Americans on the left and Germans on the right.
The vaunted Yanks, looking to blunt the spearhead of 10th Panzer Division's thrust from the north, behind Tebourba and Blade Force's advance to the east (at Djedeida and then Tuni), and here we see the combat debut of the US Tank Company Commander and his Executive Officer!
Commander: Captain Avery (in the M3 Grant, because I don't have enough M3 Stuarts and didn't want to use an M5 Stuart, which wouldn't really be an issue but I'd previously stated the two M3 Grant Platoons* were strung out across Algeria and still hadn't reached the battle area; I guess that just meant the Grant platoons, not the CO's vehicle)
Stuarts:
-1st Lieutenant Seay, filling in since both Stuart platoon leaders are out of action (Lt Figures is WIA and Lt Hastings is KIA, with no replacements as of yet)
-1st Lieutenant Seay, filling in since both Stuart platoon leaders are out of action (Lt Figures is WIA and Lt Hastings is KIA, with no replacements as of yet)
-Sgt Gibson
-Sgt Daigle
-Sgt Simpson
-Sgt Parella
M3 GMCs (halftracks mounting 75mm guns)
-2nd Lt Swayne
-Sgt "Cut-throat" Cuthbert (who won the Silver Star in his last fight, for knocking out three French tanks with three shots!)
-Sgt Johnson
*For your reference, the Tank Company has twenty-two tanks, with one each for the Company Commander and Executive Officer (which I figured would both be M3 Stuarts, but apparently one M3 Grant and one M3 Stuart), then two five-tank M3 Stuart Platoons and two five-tank M3 Grant Platoons. I plan on keeping the Grant/Stuart split through Sicily (yes, I know it should be Shermans for Sicily, but I want to keep my Grants for as long as I can!), but will change to one M5 Stuart Platoon and 3 M4 Sherman Platoons (the CO and XO will have Shermans, too) for Salerno and stay like that for the rest of the war.
The Germans:
-Commander (in a Panzer IVD. with short 75mm)
-Commander (in a Panzer IVD. with short 75mm)
-6 Panzer IVGs (with long 75mm)
-2 Panzer IIIJs (with long 50mm)
Overview, now with troops. The US force is broken into three separate elements: three Stuarts at far left, three M3 GMCs at the Walled Farm (bottom left), and the Grant and two Stuarts at bottom center left (just right of the Walled Farm), while the Germans have broken into two different elements, both at top right, but with their right-hand column looking to shoot straight west (left) and their left-hand element looking to shoot straight south (down), looking to conduct a double envelopment of the US force.
The US left-hand element is led by Lt Seay and he has Sergeants Gibson and Parella with him, while the US right-hand element is led by Captain Avery and he has Sergeants Simpson and Daigle with him. The three M3 GMC tank destroyers intend on holding down the center, with a pretty decent field of fire running north-northeast from the Walled Farm, bisecting the table.
I'm really not happy with how this looks; the last thing I want is for my opposing tanks to end up nose-to nose, practically in melee combat, the tank commanders firing their pistols at each other...
A closer look at the US setup, from west to east, with Lt Seay's group at left, the M3 GMCs at right, and Captain Avery's group just above them.
And a closeup of the two German groups.
The US wins initiative (the one time I didn't want to), and now it's time to fight!
Captain Avery leads his tanks forward on the US right.
Where a Panzer IV (long) spots him and fires...
But apparently the opposing gunners were caught out, because not only did the German round miss, so did the American's return fire!
On the US left, Lt Seay orders Sgts Gibson and Parella to hold back as he instructs his driver to ease them out cautiously for a look...
Again a German tank (bottom right) spots them (top center) and fires!
The 75mm AP round misses, but is close enough to suppress Lt Seay's crew, as Sgt Gibson orders his driver to advance at speed, pulling up next to Lt Seay's vehicle.
But it has simply drawn the attention of the next panzer in line (bottom right), which promptly fires on the two American light tanks (top center).
Sgt Gibson's Stuart (top right) is hit and immobilized, as Lt Seay screams at his driver to reverse out of the line of fire (center, from top right, with Sgt Parella looking on from far left)!!!
And then that familiar buzz of aircraft engines wafts across the valley; as many times as Task Force Reisman has already been hit by the deadly Stukas, the American tank commanders instinctively break out in a cold sweat, looking skyward, hoping beyond hope to see P-40 Warhawks, or even the new, split-tailed P-38 Lightnings...
Dammit!!!
The Stukas identify Captain Avery's column and tip over into their dives...
No US tanks are destroyed, but the bombing run is ferocious nonetheless, immobilizing Captain Avery's M3 Grant (top right), suppressing Sgt Simpson's Stuart (red bead at left), and pinning Sgt Daigle's Stuart (yellow bead at center)!!!
On top of that, the Germans rolled a 'Scurry,' which means they get to move up unmolested by the Americans, getting their guns into the firing line without having to pay for it...
Predictably, the German left-hand column pushes south (left, from bottom left, and we're looking from northeast to southwest in this photo) and the right-hand column pushes east (center bottom, from bottom center, a bit more cautiously than their left-hand comrades.
While on the US left, Sgt Parella pushes his Stuart up (bottom center, from bottom left) to help the XO out, but they're only able to rally 'up' to pinned.
While in the US center, Sgt Cuthbert and the other tank destroyers are supposed to be holding their positions at the Walled Farm, ready to engage, but he can't help himself. He sees what the German dive bombers did to Captain Avery's column, so old Cut-throat pushes his vehicle over (center, from bottom center) to help out, helping to rally Sgt Simpson's Stuart.
But now the US rolls up a 'normal' activation and a random event, which turns out to be 'A Hero Emerges.' I roll up randomly to see which unit it is...
And it turns out to be the US CO, Captain Avery! So, Captain Avery quickly shakes off the deleterious effects of the German bombs and rallies his crew back into action, then orders them to engage the German panzers!
Due to him being a hero AND the plethora of bunched up targets, I gave him a bunch (way too many?) dice to roll, 4K 3S, and he didn't disappoint! Technically speaking, that's two 'Kills' and two 'Immobilized.' I figure that's too much, so I drop the two red 1s...
Captain Avery's tank (top left) quickly knocks out two of the Panzer IVs!!!
And then, from the west (bottom left), Sgt Parella's Stuart engages the same German formation (top right, with Captain Avery's tanks just off camera to far right, and the Walled Farm just visible at bottom right)...
The 37mm AP rounds catch the lead Panzer IV (bottom left) in the flank, brewing it up!
And then Sgt Cuthbert (bottom center, at the tail of Captain Avery's formation) gets in on the act, the first US vehicle to engage the German right-hand column (top center/left, the right-hand column at top right, with three tanks already burning!)...
A Panzer IV is hit and immobilized, and its crew bales out!
As Sgt Johnson (bottom left, with Lt Seay's formation at top left) sights in and fires on the German right-hand column (top right)...
The 75mm AP round misses and skips off a nearby rockpile (bottom right) and a panzer returns fire, also missing, but missing close enough to pin Sgt Johnson (top left) and his crew.
Back with the left-hand German column, the new lead panzer (left bottom) sights in and fires on Captain Avery's M3 Grant (top center)...
I gave the German 3K 1S to fire on the big as a barn and immobilized Grant, and still they completely missed! Captain Avery is living some kinda charmed life right now.
The round zips past Captain Avery's head (bottom left) as he slews the turret and orders his gunner to return fire (yeah, have to use the 37mm, can't bring the 75mm gun into action due to being immobilized)...
The 37mm AP shot, fired at less than 200 yards, immobilizes the German tank and the crew bales out!
With things about as stymied as they can get on their left (bottom left), the Germans push up on the right (center/right)...
The lead Panzer IV circles around a nearby dune (bottom right) and fires on Sgt Johnson's tank destroyer (top left), suppressing the American halftrack.
As another panzer pushes up (center, from far right) and opens up on Sgt Gibson's Stuart (top left) at point-blank range...
The American tank crew bales out, carrying their wounded commander, Sgt Gibson.
Sgt Cuthbert (center right, at left end of Captain Avery's column) again fires on the German right-hand column (top left)...
He hits another German tank, immobilizing it, but the crew stays in the fight (despite being suppressed)!
Then Sgt Cuthbert pushes his halftrack up to the next vehicle in the column, Sgt Daigle's, trying to get them into the fight.
Sgt Daigle's crew successfully rallies, then he and Sgt Simpson push the tanks forward (center right, from bottom left).
While back on the US left, Lt Seay (yellow bead) finally manages to rally his crew, but Sgt Parella (below him) is feeling a bit antsy...
So he pushes his Stuart up next to Sgt Gibson's abandoned vehicle (center top, from bottom left).
But a German Panzer III (bottom center) spots him (top center)...
And promptly knocks Sgt Parella's tank out!
Swirling smoke and dust, flames from burning tanks, there is suddenly a lull that turns the battlefield into a very quiet place...
**The Germans rolled another Scurry.
The immobilized Panzer IV (right, who's crew stayed in it) rallies, as the three other operational tanks move up, getting very aggressive (particularly the German tank at left, moving in on Captain Avery's formation).
Sgt Daigle spots the advancing panzer (far left) and orders his driver to reverse (far right, from center)!
As Lt Swayne finally pushes his halftrack up to where it might actually be able to get in the fight (right bottom, from left bottom, with Sgt Johnson's suppressed halftrack at far left).
A Panzer III (bottom right) spots Lt Swayne's halftrack (top left) and fires, suppressing the Lieutenant and his crew!
As Lt Seay pushes his Stuart forward (bottom center, from left), around the dune, lining up a shot on the rear deck of a Panzer IV (top right). "Fire!"
But somehow Lt Seay's (top left) round has gone astray, completely missing the German tank (bottom right), which promptly faces about and engages the diminutive M3 Stuart...
Knocking out Lt Seay's tank (bottom center, with Sgt Parella's burning tank and Sgt Gibson's abandoned tank at center top)!!!
With the German tank (top left) theoretically distracted, Sgt Simpson decided now was the time to push up (center)!!!
But the veteran German panzer commander has seen a thing or two in his time and did not ignore his exposed flank; he calmly orders his driver to again face the threat as he slews the turret and orders his gunner to fire...
Captain Avery (far left) looks on helplessly from his immobilized M3 Grant as Sgt Simpson's Stuart is demolished!
The Captain has seen enough...
He sends the signal to withdraw out over the net, drops a couple thermite grenades in his tank, and abandons ship...
They don't make it far in the direction of southeast before they spot more Germans; "what the hell, where is everybody?" Captain Avery jumps in Lt Swayne's halftrack and gets on the battalion net, trying to figure out what's going on and what to do. It's a bit confused, but one thing has become abundantly clear: the Germans have advanced around Blade Force to the west, circling to cut it off, and Blade Force is actually assisting those efforts by falling back east towards Tebourba, rather than south, out of the bag, towards Medjez el Bab!!!
Turns out the idea of falling back to Tebourba was sort of valiant, that is, quite a bit of British infantry was still over there and it was good they weren't left high and dry by the armor, but it was also a bit naive; high command still hadn't really grasped how strong the German push from the north was, and that it was soon to be joined by a strong push from the east. Hadn't grasped to the point that they were still ordering attacks to the east, against Djedeida...
Well, despite it being too close because it was on too small of a table, that was still pretty damn fun! Even with losing! Turned out to be a pretty close thing, and definitely a tale of two halves: the Americans were kicking butt in the first half, annihilating the German left-hand column), only to be dominated by the German right-hand column in the second half. But it wasn't pre-ordained, didn't have to be that way: Lt Seay, Sgt Simpson, and Sgt Johnson all had shots that could have turned the tide, saved the day, but missed (damn, particularly Lt Seay's shot on the exposed rear of a Panzer IV facing Captain Avery's column). Coulda, woulda, shoulda...
Let's get to some stats:
-the US had 10 men killed, wounded, or missing
-the US had four M3 Stuarts and one M3 Grant destroyed
-the Germans had 10 men killed, wounded, or missing
-The Germans had four Pz IVGs and one Pz IIIJ destroyed
Characters:
-Captain Avery, Tank Company Commander, was awarded the Silver Star for his combat leadership leading the counterattack at Chouigoui Pass, staying in his immobilized tank to rally his men and destroy three enemy tanks.
-Sergeant Cuthbert, Tank Destroyer Commander, Tank Destroyer Platoon, was recognized for his steady and calm demeanor and professionalism whilst knocking out an enemy tank with his M3 Gun Motor Carriage, his fourth tank kill of the war.
-Sergeant Parella, Tank Commander, 1st Tank Platoon, was recognized for his steady and calm demeanor and professionalism whilst knocking out an enemy tank with his M3 Stuart, and awarded the Purple Heart for being wounded by enemy tank fire. Luckily, Sgt Parella's injuries were slight and he may return to duty in approximately two weeks' time.
-1st Lt Seay, Executive Officer, Tank Company, was awarded the Purple Heart for being wounded by enemy tank fire. Luckily, Lt Seay's injuries were slight and he was immediately able to return to duty.
-Sgt Simpson, Tank Commander, 1st Tank Platoon, was awarded the Purple Heart for being wounded by enemy tank fire. Luckily, Sgt Simpson's injuries were slight and he was immediately able to return to duty.
-Sgt Gibson, Tank Commander, 1st Tank Platoon, was awarded the Purple Heart for being wounded by enemy tank fire. Unfortunately, Sgt Gibson's injuries were so severe as to require evacuation to the United States and medical retirement.
So Blade Force as a whole has been rather roughly handled by the enemy (and it's only going to get worse), and that's true for the advanced element of Task Force Reisman as well. The Task Force crossed over into Tunisia with its Tank Company CO, XO, and two full platoons of M3 Stuarts, for a total of one M3 Grant and eleven M3 Stuarts. Major Reisman winced when he looked at the morning report and saw he could now only put three M3 Stuarts into action. Eight M3 Stuarts and the lone M3 Grant had been put out of action, and with it both platoon leaders and four other tank commanders.
So despite Blade Force suffering heavy casualties and being virtually surrounded by a seasoned opponent, high command was still intent on continuing the race for Tunis. The Germans seemed content to sit tight and let the situation develop, carrying out only light, probing attacks, as Blade Force licked its wounds and reorganized, preparing for the big push, eastwards to Djedeida, which also allowed the British to push more armor further west, back to Chouigoui, in the form of the 17/21st Hussar Regiment. Two days later and it was time to answer the bell, as the 5th Northamptonshires were stepping off in the attack, with elements of TF Reisman conducting a supporting attack on their left...
Coming right up!
V/R,
Jack
Jack
